Students at the University of Sheffield have donated four tonnes of goods to city charities. As...
Why Recent Graduates Should Join Code for America
Sympathy for the dodgy salesmen of Australian politics
Babel Rising
T.C. Boyle: Incorporating Environmentalism in Art
The Stone Roses confirm all planned shows to go ahead after Ian Brown calls Reni a 'c**t' onstage
The election Rudd could have won
The result suggests some fascinating questions. Prime among them is whether Labor panicked and threw away this election when it deposed Kevin Rudd and replaced him with Julia Gillard in June. Would Rudd have done better? The answer is probably yes.
By John Warhurst

There are a number of memorable aspects to this 2010 federal election result, but none more so than its expected result as a hung parliament, one in which neither side, Labor nor the Coalition, has achieved a majority of seats in the House of Representatives. The party leaders, Julia Gillard and Tony Abbott, now must begin negotiating with the Independents and the Green MP even before the election count is concluded.

This type of outcome, close results and often hung parliaments, is fast becoming the new Australian way. You only have to witness recent state and territory elections in Tasmania, South Australia, the Northern Territory and the Australian Capital Territory (and even Western Australia in part). Just about all of them have ended this way since the defeat of the Howard Government in November 2007. This development has not received enough attention in early post-mortems of the Federal Election.

It reflects an evenly divided electorate unconvinced by the claims of either side; as well as disillusionment with the way the political process is conducted. All of these elements were demonstrated during this campaign.

The memorable aspects include the precipitous decline and possible defeat of a first-term Labor Government, and the best-ever performance of the Greens in both houses; including their first-ever general election win in the House of Representatives in the electorate of Melbourne.

There have also been notable landmark individual performances, including those of the two Wyatts (Ken Wyatt who is likely to become the first Indigenous member of the House of Representatives by winning Hasluck in Western Australia for the Liberals; and Wyatt Roy who, at 20 years of age, has become the youngest ever member by winning Longman in Queensland for the Liberals).

Ed Husic, winning Chifley in Sydney for Labor, has become the first Muslim elected to the federal Parliament.

The result also suggests some fascinating questions. Prime among them is whether Labor panicked and threw away this election when it deposed Kevin Rudd and replaced him with Gillard in June.

Would Rudd have done better? The answer is probably yes. He would likely have done better in Queensland, though less well in the rest of the country. But on balance Labor probably would have done better given the enormity of Labor losses in Queensland (ten seats lost). This occurred even though NSW State Labor is more unpopular than Queensland State Labor. Labor did well in patches in NSW and only lost four seats.

The result delivers a remarkable opportunity to the occupants of the cross-benches. Notably they all support a greater role for government regardless of their other differences.

Originally published at Eurekastreet, click the link to read more or for more information.

blog comments powered by Disqus
 
What’s wrong with this picture?
26 jun  |  Okay, the former Australian PM wasn’t perfect, not by a long shot. He was a slave-driving workaholic. Nerdy to boot,yet absurdly keen to sell himself as “one of the blokes” knocking back beers. His mind was ordered, his family perfect, his patriotic utterances sent the nation to sleep. But he had a big heart.
By Richard Neville
 . . read more
Rudd's second apology, just as pointless?
5 apr  |  By Sean Maguire

Apologising is a uniquely human action, it involves taking responsibility for a mistake and admitting you erred. In someways it also involves asking for forgiveness.

Kevin Rudd, Australia's former PM who was sacked by his own party last year, apologised last night for "killing" his Emissions Trading Scheme which he says brought about his downfall.

Whether this is true or not, his apology echoes another one he made in his first week in government. That "sorry" was to the aboriginal people of Australia who since British colonisation were oppressed, marginalied and literally stolen from their families. 

His apology in that instance was personal and was seen almost universally as a positive step towards reconciliation and healing. It didn't lead to a better livelihood for indigenous Australians and has to be seen now as a symbolic act without much substance behind it.

Hopefully this second apology for failing on climate change can lead to asking for real forgiveness by making some real progress.    . . read more

The Curse of Krudd
11 aug  |  By Sumer Dayal

Foreseeable to everyone except for (seemingly) the Labor Party, Kevin Rudd has made his presence (or lack thereof) felt in this election.

If he’s there, the country is reminded of how he was deposed, if he’s not there the country is reminded of his rift with the Party. Either way, Kevin Rudd’s shadow holds sway over Gillard’s election campaign. Australia loves giving sympathy and it’s been long enough for Kevin Rudd to receive that. What it hasn’t been long enough for is Gillard to come across as a leader for the future. Here’s a suggestion – quit being in denial.

You screwed over your boss.

Deal with it.

Otherwise keep watching Tony Abbott basking in your foolhardiness.  . . read more

Stuck in the Rudd no more?
23 jun  |  Stuck in the Rudd no more? . . read more
Julia Gillard & the World's Pressure on Women
16 feb  |  Politics is a tough business at the best of times. Everything a politician says or does is open to public scrutiny – and this is just from a male’s point of view. Imagine what it is like from the point of view of Australia’s first female Prime Minister, Julia Gillard. Not only does she have to deal with the standard amount of public examination that comes with the office, but she is forced also to deal with the added pressure laid upon her, by the voters as well as other politicians, that stems from her being a woman. Whilst it shouldn’t be this way, and her being a woman should have no more bearing on her ability to run the country as it would had she been a man (still following?), the sad truth of the matter is that it is this way the world works.
Ben Rice- writing for HPD takes a closer look
 . . read more
Kevin Rudd's Big Climate Change Question
6 jul  |  Professor Ross Garnaut's draft report calls for an emissions trading scheme in Australia to help stop global warming. Can PM Kevin Rudd make the tough decisions to help the environment before it's too late?  . . read more
Watermelon Country
1 sep  |  We’re (still) moving forward


Despite the best efforts of Julia Gillard and the Labor machine, the results of the federal election are encouraging. It’s certainly no defeat for those committed to finding the good life beyond consumer capitalism, creating the society of the free and equal and establishing a benign relationship with the natural world.

By Hall Greenland . . read more

Bob Brown on election politics and the Greens: With Robert Manne
21 aug  |  Bob Brown on election politics and the Greens: With Robert Manne . . read more
A Day in the Life: Julia Gillard
4 aug  |  I woke up groggily to the piercing sound of my alarm, I groaned, it had been a long couple of weeks. I stood up slowly, my back and shoulders was killing me but I couldn’t work out why, it was as if tiny nails had been driven into me all over. I dressed as quickly as I could and walked down the corridor to my kitchen. It was spotless, the fruit bowl which stood on the middle of my kitchen table was empty - I chuckled to myself remembering a couple of years ago that those were the only fruits that were giving me problems, not anymore. . . read more
Do it like a lady
25 jun  |  By Sumer Dayal

Oh the glory and the celebration raking the news as we pat ourselves on the back for having our first female Prime Minister!

How quick we are to get on the bandwagon as a political disaster is turned into triumph. In case people are thinking this is a triumph for women’s lib and their position in society, don’t push it. This was not democracy at work. This was not the voice of the Australian people. It still isn’t. Australia now has a PM nobody elected and nobody considered.

At least in America the Vice-President goes on the ticket. Today I felt powerless as the Prime Minister we chose was removed with a less-than-reasonable explanation. This isn’t a victory. This was sloppy politics. Kevin Rudd couldn’t hold on to his party and got ousted. Labor isn’t united; it’s struggling to fix itself before the next election. Dear members of the Cabinet.

Whether Rudd is good or bad, it’s our call. Not yours. We chose him, we deal with him.

Give me some evidence that Rudd was doing real damage, and then this action is justifiable. And face it – a woman is Prime Minister not because anyone thought she deserved it, but purely because the man elected couldn’t do his job properly.

Nobody looked at her and said she’s the one to lead this country. Is that what a female PM means? To me, she’s just a seat-warmer. The real PM is the one we elect. So political allegiances aside, I’ll just say this. Win the election Gillard, and then you might gain my respect. Do it like a lady. Come on and show us that behind-the-Cabinet backstabbing isn’t the only way a woman can get into power.

Then maybe the Australian people might get my respect as well.  . . read more

blogs   100words
 
"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." -- Ronald Reagan (1986)